Navigating Complex Business Challenges

Some business problems have clear causes and clear solutions. Others involve many interacting factors, competing interests and genuine uncertainty. These call for a different kind of approach.

Looking up through the dark interior of a concrete building

Every organization eventually encounters a problem that does not yield to the usual approach. The obvious remedies have been tried. Different people describe the problem in different ways. Each proposed solution seems to create difficulties elsewhere. Progress, when it comes, is slow and uncertain.

Challenges of this kind are often the most consequential an organization faces. They are also the ones where the temptation to reach for a simple answer is strongest, and most unhelpful.

Complicated or complex?

It can help to distinguish between problems that are complicated and those that are complex. A complicated problem may have many parts, but those parts relate to one another in predictable ways. With enough expertise and analysis, it can be solved. Installing a new financial system is complicated: demanding, but knowable.

A complex problem is different. Its parts interact in ways that are difficult to predict, and the act of intervening changes the situation. Changing an organization's culture, repositioning a business in a shifting market, or reconciling the interests of different groups within an organization are complex problems. Expertise remains valuable, but no amount of upfront analysis will produce a guaranteed answer.

Recognizing which kind of problem one is facing matters, because the appropriate approach differs. Treating a complex problem as if it were merely complicated, by commissioning a definitive plan and expecting it to unfold as designed, is a common source of frustration.

Treating a complex problem as merely complicated is a common source of frustration.

Giving the problem structure

Complexity does not mean that analysis is futile. It means analysis must be used differently. A useful first step is simply to describe the problem carefully: what is happening, where, since when, and with what effect. Many complex challenges are discussed for months without anyone writing down a clear account of them.

From there, it is often possible to identify the main elements of the problem and how they influence one another. Some elements will be within the organization's control and some will not. Some will be well understood and others uncertain. Separating these allows effort to be directed where it can make a difference, and makes visible the areas where the organization will need to proceed cautiously.

Many perspectives

Complex challenges usually involve people who see the situation differently, often for good reasons. A sales team, an operations team and a finance team may each have a partial and accurate view of the same problem. Each view, on its own, leads to a different solution.

Bringing these perspectives together is not merely a matter of courtesy. It is how a fuller picture of the problem emerges. An outside adviser can sometimes help here, by creating a setting in which views can be expressed candidly and by drawing them into a coherent whole without favoring any single position in advance.

Making progress under uncertainty

Because complex problems cannot be fully understood in advance, progress tends to come through a sequence of considered steps rather than a single decisive intervention. Each step is chosen on the basis of the best current understanding, its effects are observed, and the next step is adjusted accordingly.

  • Favor actions that are reasonably reversible when uncertainty is high.
  • Decide in advance what would indicate that an approach is working, or is not.
  • Keep the overall objective clearly in view, even as the route toward it changes.
  • Communicate openly that the approach is deliberate and adaptive, so that adjustments are not mistaken for failure.

This requires patience and a degree of comfort with ambiguity, qualities that can be difficult to sustain under pressure. But for the most difficult challenges, a steady, well-reasoned approach usually achieves more than the search for a single comprehensive solution. Complexity rewards persistence, structure and judgment far more than it rewards speed.

This article reflects the general perspective of Stigs Consulting and is not advice for any specific situation. If you would like to discuss how these ideas apply to your organization, please contact us.