Making Better Organizational Decisions

Organizations make countless decisions, and a handful of them matter enormously. The quality of those decisions depends not only on who makes them, but on how they are made.

A curving concrete stair with a tree at its centre

When an important decision turns out badly, the post-mortem usually focuses on the outcome: what went wrong, and who should have seen it coming. Less attention is paid to the process that produced the decision in the first place. Yet process is where much of the difference between good and poor decisions lies, and, unlike outcomes, it is largely within an organization's control.

Good decision-making is not a matter of eliminating uncertainty. That is rarely possible. It is a matter of approaching uncertain choices in a way that gives the organization the best reasonable chance of choosing well.

Framing the decision

Many decisions go astray before any analysis begins, because the question itself is poorly framed. A team asked whether to open a new location may never consider whether growth would be better pursued another way. A leadership group debating which system to buy may not have agreed what problem the system is meant to solve.

Taking time at the outset to state the decision clearly is time well spent. What exactly is being decided? What objective is the decision meant to serve? What constraints genuinely apply, and which are simply assumed? A well-framed question narrows the field to what matters and makes the subsequent discussion far more productive.

A well-framed question narrows the field to what matters.

Widening the options

Decisions are often presented as a choice between two alternatives: to proceed or not, to choose option A or option B. Framing a decision this way can obscure better possibilities. Before evaluating options, it is worth asking whether the right options are on the table at all.

Practical ways to widen the field include asking what the organization would do if neither leading option were available, considering whether elements of different options could be combined, and asking whether the decision could be staged, testing an approach on a smaller scale before committing fully. Even when the final choice is one of the original options, considering alternatives sharpens understanding of why it is the right one.

Separating evidence from assumption

In most significant decisions, the available information is a mixture of established fact, reasonable inference and assumption. Problems arise when these are not distinguished, when a hopeful projection is treated with the same confidence as an audited figure, or when a long-held belief goes unexamined because no one thinks to question it.

A useful discipline is to identify, for each option, the few assumptions on which its success most depends, and then to ask how confident the organization really is in each. Where confidence is low and the stakes are high, it may be worth gathering more information before deciding. Where confidence is low but further information is unavailable, the decision should at least be made with that uncertainty in view.

It also helps to create space for disagreement. Senior teams can drift toward consensus too quickly, particularly when a respected leader has expressed a view early. Inviting challenge deliberately, by asking someone to make the strongest case against the preferred option for instance, can surface concerns that would otherwise go unspoken.

Deciding, and learning

Analysis should support a decision, not postpone it indefinitely. At some point, further deliberation adds less value than the cost of delay. Recognizing that point, and committing with appropriate confidence once it is reached, is part of good decision-making.

Once a decision is made, recording the reasoning behind it, including the key assumptions and the alternatives considered, is a modest habit with real benefits. It allows the organization to revisit the decision intelligently if circumstances change, and to learn from it afterwards. Over time, organizations that reflect on how they decide, and not only on what they decided, tend to decide better.

This article reflects the general perspective of Stigs Consulting and is not advice for any specific situation. If you would like to discuss how these ideas apply to your organization, please contact us.